
How to design a calibration session that does not turn into a negotiation over scores
How do you keep a calibration session from turning into a negotiation over scores? Bring evidence, context, and criteria into the conversation before the number.
Articles about accountability, boundaries, and the responsible use of talent systems.
33 articles

How do you keep a calibration session from turning into a negotiation over scores? Bring evidence, context, and criteria into the conversation before the number.

Even when usage is high, a model may not yet have been adopted: the decisive evidence appears when it changes a real decision and that change can be reconstructed.

Should the organization create a new role or redistribute the work? The answer depends on the stability, distinctiveness, and accountability of the missing contribution.

What does a space without a conclusion actually mean? It may indicate an absence of observation, an expectation outside the role, or insufficient evidence. Distinguishing these states prevents us from assigning a gap that the data does not demonstrate.

What makes an assessment valid for a specific decision? The answer connects the intended use with the evidence required, the interpretation that can be supported, and the limits of any conclusion.

Even when the initial test works, different areas begin to interpret the model in incompatible ways as it expands. Preserving quality requires distinguishing the meaning that must remain stable from the methods that can be adapted.

A score summarizes evidence obtained under certain rules, sources, and conditions. When language turns it into a definition of who the person is, a time-bound measurement begins to govern expectations, opportunities, and new interpretations.

Recording an observation can improve a development conversation. Recording everything, all the time, changes the relationship: it stops producing useful evidence and starts producing surveillance.

Who can change a skill, approve a level, or decide that the evidence is sufficient to use a result? These three decisions require different authorities.