
The leader who assesses without observing
The authority to assess comes with the role. The quality of the judgment comes from the evidence. When the two are confused, familiarity, reputation, and visible results take the place of observation.
Articles about designing, interpreting, and using evidence to assess capabilities with sound judgment.
38 articles

The authority to assess comes with the role. The quality of the judgment comes from the evidence. When the two are confused, familiarity, reputation, and visible results take the place of observation.

Noise brings an uncomfortable idea to talent decisions: two competent assessors can apply the same criteria and reach different conclusions for reasons the system never deliberately chose to accept.

A perception does not capture reality like a camera. It does, however, record how someone interprets what they could observe within a particular relationship, at a particular moment, and against specific expectations. That limitation does not make perception irrelevant; it determines how perception should be read.

Pulse, Check, Interview, and Target can coexist within the same assessment architecture, but they are not longer or shorter versions of the same instrument. Each mode answers a different question, produces a different kind of evidence, and supports conclusions with a distinct scope.

Reassessing too soon can mistake a recent activity for a developed capability. Reassessing too late leaves unanswered a question that could already be resolved. The right time depends not only on the calendar, but also on opportunities to practice, the quality of the evidence, and the stability of the change.

Missing evidence, conflicting evidence, and uncertainty are not the same problem. When they are collapsed into a generic category, an organization may manufacture certainty, defer a decision indefinitely, or treat something it has not yet observed as a gap.

An assessment that returns only a score provides less information than it used to reach its conclusion. The person needs to understand the result, the evidence behind it, its limitations, and what they can do with it.

An average can accurately represent the center of several results while concealing the difference that matters most to the decision. Its usefulness depends on which components it combines and which of them may compensate for one another.

A scale reduces differences in interpretation when it requires assessors to recognize the same evidence—not when it replaces vague words with more elegant labels. Designing one means defining what will be observed, making the boundaries between levels explicit, and testing those boundaries with cases that reveal where disagreement begins.

A skill is a useful construct for organizing capabilities, but an assessment cannot access it directly. It accesses decisions, explanations, procedures, outcomes, and behaviors produced under specific conditions.

A skill is a useful construct for organizing capabilities, but it never appears as a complete object to the person assessing it. What we see are partial manifestations in specific tasks, decisions, and contexts.

Choosing who should assess a skill is not a search for the most reliable source. It is an exercise in identifying who had sufficient access to the behaviors, decisions, and outcomes relevant to the conclusion we need to draw.