
What evidence an internal transition needs to stop being a gamble
Deciding on an internal transition requires four pieces of evidence. They must separate transferable capability, adaptation still needed, confirmed gaps, and entry conditions.
Articles about designing, interpreting, and using evidence to assess capabilities with sound judgment.
38 articles

Deciding on an internal transition requires four pieces of evidence. They must separate transferable capability, adaptation still needed, confirmed gaps, and entry conditions.

Sources of Power makes it possible to treat expert intuition as situated recognition without turning experience or confidence into unquestionable authority.

A correlation between skills and outcomes is useful for opening an investigation. A claim of contribution requires an explanation of the mechanism, the timing, and the alternatives.

A 360 improves an assessment when it preserves what each source observed, from which relationship, and within what limits; averaging first destroys that information.

How do you keep a calibration session from turning into a negotiation over scores? Bring evidence, context, and criteria into the conversation before the number.

What does a space without a conclusion actually mean? It may indicate an absence of observation, an expectation outside the role, or insufficient evidence. Distinguishing these states prevents us from assigning a gap that the data does not demonstrate.

What makes an assessment valid for a specific decision? The answer connects the intended use with the evidence required, the interpretation that can be supported, and the limits of any conclusion.

Before using a skills architecture to assess people, validate it by testing its definitions against real decisions, deliverables, and situations.

Confidence becomes visible before competence does. It appears in the speed of a response, the firmness of a voice, and the willingness to take up space. Competence, by contrast, can be supported only by relevant evidence of what a person can do under specific conditions.

Knowing What Students Know was written for educational assessment, but its central question applies to any system that tries to evaluate capabilities: how do we move from what someone does in a specific situation to a defensible inference about what they know and can do?

A poorly designed assessment often reveals its flaws before producing results. The following signs help detect problems in what is being assessed, the questions, the evidence, the scales, and the intended use while the design can still be corrected.

When a leader distrusts a skills assessment, the usual reaction is to attribute it to resistance to change. But distrust may also point to genuine problems with burden, observation, interpretation, or consequences that the design has not yet resolved.