Three circular ceramic platforms on metal legs; a blue bar connects two, leaving the third unconnected.

Selling also commits capacity

A sale also commits dates and shared capacity. How to distinguish an indicative date, a reservation and a confirmed start before passing the risk on to delivery.

Alejandro Mayorga5 min read

Two clients receive proposals to start an implementation in the same week. The service is familiar, and the company has a team capable of providing it, but only one project can begin in that window. Each offer, considered separately, looks viable. The case is hypothetical, and the difficulty is not a faulty estimate: both proposals are counting on the same availability. While they remain open, the company may have good reasons to keep both in play. If both are confirmed, it will need more than two successfully closed sales.

Planning thus enters the conversation before the order. Work by Kingsman and his colleagues on make-to-order manufacturing (opens in a new tab) already considered quotations, promised lead times and workload together. Not because every sale had to become an exercise in industrial scheduling, but because the act of making a promise was part of the problem production would later have to solve. In services, that relationship is visible without importing the entire model: having the expertise needed for an implementation does not ensure that it will be available in the week offered.

Work that is not yet under contract

Reserving capacity for every inquiry would not solve the problem either. The company could let projects pass while waiting for confirmations that never come. A sales opportunity has some probability of becoming work, but it is not yet that work. The difficulty is to retain that uncertainty in the decision without letting it disappear from the calendar simply because there is no order yet.

A simulation published by Thürer and his colleagues in 2013 (opens in a new tab) examined precisely this question of contingent orders when setting due dates in make-to-order shops. Under the conditions studied, the best-performing rule included that workload when estimating lead times. The simulation does not establish how much capacity a consulting firm should reserve or how it should organize its projects. It provides a precedent for taking unconfirmed demand seriously, rather than choosing between treating it as certain and ignoring it.

In our example, it matters to know what could change if both clients accept. Perhaps one could agree to another week, additional support could be brought in, or an initial stage might not need the full team. Each alternative depends on something that must be checked. A future hire with no confirmed availability date cannot, by itself, support the start already offered. Nor is it inconsequential to move a client who has prepared their operation to receive the service.

Susan Slotnick’s review of order acceptance and scheduling (opens in a new tab) brings together models that consider, among other costs, delays that a new order may impose on earlier ones. That relationship changes the commercial assessment: a sale attractive for its revenue may require renegotiation or consume capacity another obligation needed. It may still be a good choice. Its value must include those consequences, rather than depend on someone finding a way to absorb them later.

What changes when a sale is won

If the first client confirms, the second proposal can no longer rely on the same availability without being reviewed. It may still be indicative, in which case updating it could be enough. If the company had also reserved that window for the second client, it will have to decide how to honor both commitments or discuss the change. What matters is doing so while alternatives remain, rather than waiting for the overlap to become a delivery emergency.

Not every offer needs to reach senior management. But the conditions for offering and reserving a date do need to reflect the capacity projects share. Anyone authorized to prioritize a sale also needs to be able to examine which work it displaces. If all they know is the new revenue and the requested deadline, part of the business they are deciding about is missing.

The company can deliberately accept the risk of several opportunities being confirmed at once. It can even prepare to lose a sale that cannot fit the requested conditions. Both choices have costs. Leaving them implicit allows each area to believe it is doing its part: Sales won the projects, and the team will have to find a way to start them. For those receiving that demand, however, the commercial decision already takes the form of an obligation.

Commercial uncertainty will not disappear. We can accept it, negotiate its conditions and prepare a response; we should not leave the client to discover through a delay what risk we had accepted. When we offer a firm date, they should be able to rely on more than our hope of losing another sale.